Follow Voicebox on Twitter Follow Voicebox on Facebook
Follow Voicebox on Facebook

A Vanished San Francisco, Black, White and Colorful

December 6, 2009

In 1952, when the budding photographer Gerald Ratto was a 19-year-old student at the California School of Fine Arts, he spent much of his time in the Fillmore district of San Francisco. Wandering around the neighborhood with his Rolleiflex camera and a bottle of brandy, he shared drinks and conversation with the residents and snapped pictures of the local kids as they played in the street.

Nearly six decades have passed since he photographed those children. Mr. Ratto, now 76, went on to lead a successful career as an architectural photographer. And the neighborhood, a bustling hub of black culture in the late 1940s and early 1950s, underwent an ill-conceived redevelopment in the 1960s and then significant growth in recent years.

When viewed against the backdrop of that tremendous transformation, Mr. Ratto’s images poignantly recall a vanished landscape. Although the pictures demonstrate an artist’s promise, his photographs do not quite satisfy as either works of art or social documents.

On display in downtown San Francisco at the Robert Tat Gallery, a space specializing in vintage photography, the compact show “Children of the Fillmore, 1952” consists of 52 silver gelatin prints, 18 of which are on display. (The other 34 pictures can be viewed upon request.)

The quality most evident in Mr. Ratto’s photographs is their innocence. Images like one depicting three small girls cuddling and smiling at the camera in what looks like their Sunday best (No. 5 in the series) and another of a boy with a cardboard box on his head and a clownish, gap-toothed grin (No. 14) convey a sense of pure-spirited delight. Meanwhile, there’s an arresting candor and warmth to the photograph of a boy sitting on a staircase with his elbows propped up behind him (No. 20). His posture and face display unfettered openness.

Most of the pictures are posed. They are also uncompromisingly shot head-on and close to their subjects. Yet they refreshingly lack affectation. Clearly, taking the time to get to know the people he photographed paid off for Mr. Ratto. Using the kind of camera that could be operated down by his waist rather than in front of his face, thus allowing him to maintain eye contact with his subjects, doubtless also helped him to earn the trust of the local youngsters.

But pictures depicting the freshness of childhood, though they look great on kitchen calendars, can veer into cutesy cliché. There’s something static and lifeless about Mr. Ratto’s portraits that undercuts their artistic strength. The images of great chroniclers of urban life, like Helen Levitt and Henri Cartier-Bresson, avoid this problem. Levitt’s famous picture of two children, one white and one black, dancing in the middle of a New York street, and Cartier-Bresson’s image of a boy rounding a corner cradling two enormous glass bottles, possess a kinetic energy and distinct personality that ultimately tell the viewer much more about the lives — and environments — of their subjects than Mr. Ratto’s photographs.

The grown-up worldliness that tinges Ms. Levitt’s pictures of children sharply undercuts their sweetness. “In each child, from very early, the germ of the death of childhood is at work,” the author James Agee says of Ms. Levitt’s photographs in his preface to her 1965 book, “A Way of Seeing.” It is this germ that makes Ms. Levitt’s photographs so powerful from a social as well as an artistic perspective. Lacking this quality, Mr. Ratto’s pictures don’t carry the same weight.

If they don’t function completely satisfactorily as works of art, the “Children of the Fillmore” images similarly lack strength as social documents of a neighborhood’s lost heritage. To the extent that the figures depicted in Mr. Ratto’s photographs appear frozen in time, the series draws attention to the vast gap between the neighborhood’s glory days and now. But with their atmosphere of utopian innocence and no hint of foreboding for the neighborhood’s future fall, the images seem naïve when viewed with contemporary eyes.

Gentrification has changed the face of the neighborhood once again. Although the area has revived, thanks to the appearance of institutions like the jazz club Yoshi’s and the spruced-up Sundance Kabuki cinemas, the black population has dwindled, owing to steep rises in the cost of goods and housing.

The district has been trying hard to reconnect with its past in recent years, with the Fillmore Heritage Center at the forefront of the campaign. The center presents historically oriented art shows, like the current exhibition of photographs of musicians shot by Dan Dion at the famed Fillmore Auditorium and a recent show of Mr. Ratto’s work.

These exhibitions might pique the curiosity of a tourist, rock music fan or local historian. But nostalgia for a bygone era ultimately isn’t very helpful to a neighborhood like the Fillmore, which, like most communities, can never hope to recapture its past in any concrete sense.

“Children of the Fillmore, 1952” continues through Jan. 30 at the Robert Tat Gallery, 49 Geary Street, No. 211; (415) 781-1122,



  • This is a cruel critique and lacks human touch. These images aren't to be compared to images from completely different environments and circumstances. These are beautiful photographs of children. And the innocence, love and spirit that children hold. Children outside on the streets, an almost forbidden phenomena these days. Children showing heart and soul. How can that harm or be negative for the Fillmore neighborhood? These are a positive, fresh document of a community that existed. And a childhood that is forever gone.

    By Blogger Andrea, At December 9, 2009 at 10:28 AM  

  • mature single woman confession [URL=]adult dating in jackson[/URL] fres dating sites gay lesbian dating service nova scotia [URL=]dating site jewish single[/URL] free adult dating australia free christian dating sites salt lake city [URL=]online sex chat dating sites[/URL] rogers gay dating free sex dating wallaceburg [URL=]deaf dating sites[/URL] sex dating in fairbanks alaska dating gay sudbury ontario [URL=]college university dating online[/URL] free adult dating farmville virginia adult dating lesbian [URL=]latin dating site girl[/URL] dating websites for teens ages a safe free dating online service [URL=]online dating safety[/URL] susan boyle tour adult dating right now pc speed dating [URL=]speeding dating fort worth tx[/URL] christian parent guide to teen dating adult sex dating in midway mississippi [URL=]sex dating in warroad minnesota[/URL] dating sex nude the dating game curriculum kit [URL=]background checks and online dating[/URL] gay dating number

    By Anonymous Anonymous, At December 10, 2009 at 12:59 AM  

  • Good day !.
    You re, I guess , probably very interested to know how one can collect a huge starting capital .
    There is no initial capital needed You may begin earning with as small sum of money as 20-100 dollars.

    AimTrust is what you haven`t ever dreamt of such a chance to become rich
    The firm incorporates an offshore structure with advanced asset management technologies in production and delivery of pipes for oil and gas.

    Its head office is in Panama with affiliates around the world.
    Do you want to become an affluent person?
    That`s your choice That`s what you desire!

    I feel good, I began to get income with the help of this company,
    and I invite you to do the same. If it gets down to select a proper companion who uses your funds in a right way - that`s it!.
    I take now up to 2G every day, and my first deposit was 1 grand only!
    It`s easy to join , just click this link
    and lucky you`re! Let`s take this option together to become rich

    By Anonymous Anonymous, At December 17, 2009 at 1:41 AM  

  • WTF is everyone talking about? I grew up in San Francisco in the '50's.. I was down in the Fillmore all the time in the '60's... I remember the 'Mo when the Chicago Barber Shop was there with it's swirling red white and blue barber shop sign..

    By Blogger Ross Portugeis, At December 17, 2009 at 9:26 PM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home